Easy 3 Ingredient Yogurt Pie

This 3 ingredient yogurt pie is the perfect sweet treat. It is easy to make, high in protein, and is a single serving so you do not have to share this creamy pie.

I was trying to come up with a fun, Valentine’s recipe, but the items I originally wanted were not at the grocery store. As soon as I saw the mini graham cracker crusts I knew I had to make something with them. The best part about this recipe is that it requires no baking so you can put it together in 5 minutes’ time!

I really enjoy greek yogurt because of the flavor, texture, and protein count. But you should know, this recipe is open to interpretation. Change the base, change the toppings, use regular yogurt, or strawberry yogurt, and make it yours!

If you do not love the yogurt flavor and want to try to make this more of a mini cheesecake, mix plain yogurt, with a bit of whipped cream cheese, add a small amount of stevia, top it with fresh fruit and you are all set! 

Ingredients:

• 1 mini pre-made graham cracker crust
• 1 vanilla Greek yogurt, I use Light&Fit, or Aldi’s protein yogurt (150 grams)
• Chocolate whipped cream, I got this from Aldi
• Fresh berries *optional

Instructions:

1. Remove one mini graham cracker crust from the package
2. Using a mini rubber spatula, scoop the yogurt cup into the pie, smooth the top
3. Spray the chocolate whipped cream on top of the pie and finish off with raspberries or any fresh fruit of your choice

Do you have to bake yogurt pie?

This is a no bake dessert recipe. It takes 5 minutes to make, and you can eat it right away, no setting or baking time is required.

How do you store yogurt pie?

This is a single-serving recipe, but if you want to make multiple to prep for the week, cover them with plastic wrap and store them in the refrigerator for up to 7 days.

Can you make multiple servings of the 3 ingredient yogurt pie?

If you have unexpected guests and you want to make them a perfect dessert in minimum time you can double, triple, or even quadruple this recipe!

What are other ingredient combinations?

I love this recipe because you are able to make it with all different flavors. You could even use oreo crust instead of a graham cracker crust… yum! Here are some filling ideas:

• Strawberry yogurt topped with cool whip and fresh strawberries
• Key lime greek yogurt topped with whipped cream and lime twists
• Vanilla greek yogurt topped with chocolate whipped cream and mini chocolate chips
• Blueberry greek yogurt topped with streusel crumbs and drizzled with maple syrup 
• Lemon yogurt topped with cool whip and lemon curd

The yogurt flavors are endless, create whatever comes to mind and make sure you tag me on social @haleynicolefit.

Can you make a frozen yogurt pie?

If you want this to be a frozen yogurt pie, follow the instructions up until number 2. Place the mini pie in the freezer for 1 hour, then top with whipped cream and berries.

What is the nutrition information for the 3-ingredient yogurt pie?

If you make this recipe with 1 mini pre-made pie crust, 1 Light&Fit Greek yogurt, and chocolate whipped cream the nutrition is as follows: 195 calories, 5.5g fat, 23g carbohydrates, and 13g protein. You can search HNFIT Mini Yogurt Pie in My Fitness Pal for easy logging.

Where can you find chocolate whipped cream?

This whipped cream is so delicious, I highly recommend it for this recipe. I was able to find it at Aldi, they also have a Salted Caramel flavor as well!

I promise you are going to love this, the hardest part of this recipe is deciding what flavors to add! Make sure to tag me on Instagram or TikTok @haleynicolefit if you make this!

If you want other Valentine’s Day Inspired recipes take a look at my Keep It Sweet Valentine’s Day Cookbook here.

Other recipes you will like:

• High Protein Greek Yogurt
• Single Serve Strawberry Shortcake
• Chocolate Covered Protein Brownies 
• Jello Yogurt Bowl
• Lemon Poppyseed Mug cake
• M&M Cakemix Cookies
• Fruit Salad with Cool Whip